All resources

Blog

How do I choose a performance marketing agency for my e-commerce brand?

Choose on how an agency measures results, not on how big it is. The right agency reports new customers separately from returning ones, tests whether branded search and affiliate spend is incremental, works month to month, and tells you who it isn't for.

Published

The short answer

Most lists of the best performance marketing agencies rank them by size, awards or client logos. None of those tell you whether an agency will find new customers for your brand. The better test is how an agency measures its own work, how it gets paid, and how easily you can leave.

An agency worth hiring reports new customers separately from returning ones, tests whether your spend is incremental, ties its fee to an agreed result, and doesn't need a long contract to keep you.

Start with what you need the agency to do

Before you compare agencies, be clear about which channels you need help with and where your program is today. An agency that is good at launching brands is not always good at fixing a program that has been spending for years, and the reverse is also true.

  • Which channels do you need run: Google Ads, affiliate, Amazon, or several?
  • Is your program already spending, or are you starting from nothing?
  • Which number do you want to move: new customers, revenue, or profit?
  • Who on your team will own the relationship?

Five things to check in any agency

  • Reporting. Does it separate new customers from returning ones, or count every sale the channel touched?
  • Incrementality. Does it test whether branded search and coupon partners bring in sales you wouldn't have had anyway?
  • Fit. Does it focus on brands like yours, and will it say plainly who it doesn't take?
  • Terms. How long is the contract, and what happens if you want to leave?
  • Pricing. Is the fee tied to hours, a fixed retainer, or the result you agree on?

Look for an agency that says who it isn't for

An agency that takes every client is optimizing for its own growth. One that turns business away has decided what it is good at. SocialLynx, for example, works with e-commerce and DTC brands that already spend on Google Ads or affiliate, mostly in apparel, lifestyle, kids and sports. It doesn't take brands that haven't launched a program, startups, SaaS companies, or brands in cannabis, alcohol, gambling, GLP-1 or tobacco.

Check credentials, then check reviews you can verify

Platform credentials show that an agency meets a platform's standards. For Google Ads, look for Google Partner status. For affiliate, look for partner status on the networks you use. SocialLynx is a certified Google Ads Partner and an impact.com Gold Partner and Certified Managing Partner, and it works on Impact.com, AWIN, CJ Affiliate and Rakuten Advertising.

Then read reviews on a third-party site such as Clutch, where clients write in their own words. Look for reviews that describe what changed, not only that the team was pleasant to work with.

Red flags

  • The pitch starts with how much more you should spend.
  • Reports show total revenue and ROAS, with no line for new customers.
  • A long contract is required before any results are shown.
  • The agency only talks about the channels it runs, never the rest of your budget.
  • Nobody can explain how the fee is set.

Use a free audit to compare

The easiest way to compare agencies is to see what each would change in your accounts. SocialLynx starts every engagement with a free audit of your Google Ads, your affiliate program and the rest of the budget. You see where spend is buying customers you already had before you agree to anything. Ask every agency on your shortlist for the same thing and compare the answers.