All resources

Blog

How do I fix an affiliate program that only rewards coupon sites?

Connect the program to your analytics so you can see which partners bring in new customers, renegotiate or replace the coupon and deal partners that only claim sales at checkout, and recruit publishers and creators who introduce your brand to new people. Expect about two months.

Published

The short answer

An affiliate program drifts toward coupon sites because most tracking pays the last partner clicked before the sale, and coupon sites sit closest to checkout. The fix has three parts: measure which partners bring in new customers, change the deals with partners that don't, and recruit publishers who reach people who weren't already coming.

How to tell how bad it is

Pull last quarter's affiliate sales and sort them by partner. For the top ten, note what kind of site each one is and whether its customers had bought from you before. If most of the list is coupon, deal or cashback sites and most of the buyers were returning customers, your commission is paying for sales you already had.

Step 1: connect the program to your analytics

Your affiliate platform reports what partners claim. Your analytics platform shows who the customer was. Connecting the two is what makes net-new growth measurable, and it is the first thing SocialLynx does in a rebuild.

Step 2: change the deals with partners at checkout

You don't have to cut every coupon partner. Some may bring in customers who wouldn't have bought otherwise, and the data from step 1 will show which. For the rest, renegotiate commission so it reflects what they add, or swap them for partners that fit the brand better.

  • Pay a lower rate on sales from returning customers.
  • Stop rewarding partners whose sales arrive only after the cart is already full.
  • Keep the partners whose customers are new to the brand.

Step 3: recruit publishers and creators who introduce your brand

Top-of-funnel publishers write reviews, gift guides and content that make someone want your product before they're ready to buy. Creators do the same with an audience that already trusts them. These partners are harder to recruit than coupon sites, which is why relationships matter. SocialLynx works with a network of 1,000+ publishers and is an impact.com Gold Partner and Certified Managing Partner.

Step 4: report on new customers

Once the program is rebuilt, judge it on new-customer revenue and incrementality, not on total affiliate revenue. Total revenue is what made the coupon problem look like growth in the first place.

How long it takes

Expect about two months. Unwinding old deals and recruiting new publishers takes time, and SocialLynx calls this a grace period and says so up front. It works month to month, so you're not locked in during the rebuild.

What it looked like for Pins & Aces

Pins & Aces, a golf apparel and accessories brand, said its old program "was mostly bottom-of-funnel and hard to trust." SocialLynx moved the program to the Impact network, renegotiated deals with affiliates and publishers, swapped in partners that fit the brand better, and set up and manages its creators. ROI from the program tripled and cost per acquisition fell 15%, with more new customers coming from affiliates.

Where to start

SocialLynx rebuilds programs that are already running on Impact.com, AWIN, CJ Affiliate or Rakuten Advertising. It doesn't launch first-time programs. The free audit shows which of your partners introduce customers and which intercept them.